Home > Dáil Éireann debate. Non-Fatal Offences against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023 [Seanad]: Second Stage.

[Oireachtas] Dáil Éireann debate. Non-Fatal Offences against the Person (Amendment) (Spiking) Bill 2023 [Seanad]: Second Stage. (12 Nov 2026)

External website: https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/debates/debate/dail/2...


Deputy Barry Ward: I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

It is my very great pleasure to introduce the Bill on Second Stage because this a Bill that I introduced as a Senator along with my colleagues in the Seanad on 25 May 2023. It went through all Stages, including Second Stage on 31 May 2023, Committee and Remaining Stages on 12 July and 25 October 2023, respectively. It passed those Stages in the Seanad, and it was sponsored by the Fine Gael group of Senators at the time, which included Regina Doherty, now an MEP and who continues to be very supportive of this Bill; Senator Ahearn who is now the Leader of the Seanad; Paddy Burke; Senator Maria Byrne, now the Leas-Chathaoirleach of the Seanad; Micheál Carrigy now a TD; Senator Martin Conway; Deputy John Cummins, now a Minister of State; Deputu Emer Currie, now the deputy Government Chief Whip; Aisling Dolan; Seán Kyne, now a TD; Tim Lombard; John McGahon; Senator Joe O'Reilly; Mary Seery-Kearney; and me. It was brought to me by members of Young Fine Gael. It had a campaign, which it rather pointedly called PricklessNights. It was about the experiences that they and their members had in pubs and clubs throughout the length and breadth of this country. They saw that this was an area of concern for people and brought it to us as a Seanad team.

We were very happy to take that and turn it into legislation, the import of which makes it a stand-alone offence in Irish law.

I acknowledge the presence in the Public Gallery of the current president of Young Fine Gael, Jamie Malone, but also his predecessors, Art O'Mahony and Eoghan Gallagher, who was president at the time. I also acknowledge the support they had from Spiking in Ireland, in particular Mary Crilly, whom I spoke to last week about this Bill. She was very helpful in identifying the policy pathway that could be taken to establish this as a Private Member's Bill. It is rare for somebody to have the opportunity to introduce a Bill in one House, bring it through all Stages and then happen to find themselves in the other House to carry on the baton as it is moved here, but it is my great pleasure to do so.

As I said, the Bill puts spiking on its own statutory footing. There is a lot of debate about whether spiking is an offence. It probably is, in reality. Spiking is when a person with a nefarious intention essentially puts a substance in someone's drink that incapacitates, drugs or makes them unconscious. It can also be introduced through a very fine needle or done in some way for them to ingest a substance that causes them to essentially lose control of their faculties and no longer be able to deal with situations they might otherwise be able to repel. The intention is usually for a nefarious purpose, very often for sexual assault or worse. Unfortunately, this is the experience of many people all over Ireland.

When we talk about spiking, we probably imagine it in a nightclub in Dublin. However, that is not the only place spiking takes place. Spiking can happen to anyone, anywhere and of any age in any circumstance, and it does. While this was initiated by Young Fine Gael and we are happy to take on board the research it has done and the feedback it has given us, it is something that affects every sector of society. The danger is we pass this off as a young person's issue when, in fact, it has the potential to affect all of us. Unfortunately, I suspect everybody in this Chamber has dealt with somebody in their constituency who has been the victim of spiking. It is something that happens all the time and, unfortunately, very often those instances are not reported to gardaí, which is another problem.

The debate regarding whether it is an offence comes down to the fact it does not have a stand-alone status in legislation as the offence of spiking. I suspect it is an offence under the non-fatal offences Act already, either as a poison or as a simple assault, as it requires the application of pressure in an illegal context. That argument could be made, but the difficulty is where there is a debate on whether something is an offence, this automatically diminishes the status of that act as a criminal act. Here, we are sending out a very clear signal that not only gives it status in itself, but it also says to anybody contemplating this activity that spiking somebody's drink or food with a substance that is going to incapacitate them is a very serious criminal offence. With this legislation, we are trying to send out a loud and clear signal to anybody involved in this activity that they will be caught, prosecuted and there will be serious consequences. The best way to do that is to give this offence a stand-alone status. That is why this Bill essentially amends the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997 to create that, and I will go through some provisions of the Bill to be clear on what it does.

Section 1 deals with definitions or interpretations within the Bill as it stands, and hopefully the Act as it will be. It talks about the terms used. The main offence is set out in section 2, which describes spiking as an offence in subsection 1 as follows:

(1) A person commits an offence if he or she intentionally - (a) administers a substance to,(b) by whatever means, injects a substance into, or (c) otherwise causes a substance to be taken orally by, another person - (i) knowing that the other person does not consent, or being reckless as to whether or not the other person consents, and (ii) with the intention of overpowering, or sedating the other person, for the purposes of - (I) engaging in a sexual act involving the other person, (II) causing harm to the other person, (III) making a gain, (IV) causing a loss to the other person, or (V) otherwise committing an offence with, or against, the person.

There are a couple of savers in section 2 as well, that in any proceedings for an offence under the section that, "it shall be a defence for a person to prove that the substance was administered, injected or otherwise given - (a) for a lawful reason or with a lawful excuse, or (b) with the other person’s express and conscious consent." That is a saver to exclude any medical treatment or any circumstances where such a substance is used. Very often, the substances used for spiking are substances that have a legitimate medical application but are being used illegally by a person for their effect. Section 2(3) sets out the penalties for a person guilty of an offence stating they are liable "on summary conviction", which is in the District Court without a jury, "to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months, or to a class A fine, or to both". However, in the case it is prosecuted on indictment, paragraph (b) states it will be "on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years". That is a significant penalty. It also sets out that penalty in the context of what I have said regarding the debate as to whether this is an offence, or what way it would be charged in the event a complaint was successfully upheld. This Bill sets out very clearly the range of penalties available to the Circuit Court in the event it is prosecuted successfully on indictment, and that is up to ten years' imprisonment.

The Bill also makes a clear statement about the level of seriousness that plays on the spectrum of criminal offences where we are pitching this matter as being at ten years. It is up there among the most serious offences that could be dealt with by the Circuit Court. We are talking about very serious stuff here. Just imagine what spiking really is. More often than not it affects women, but it is both and can be all ages, but when a person in a pub is on a night out, let us say, and somebody pops something in their drink, injects something into them or puts something in their food, they are incapacitated. They are not necessarily unconscious; they might just be in a dreamlike state, but they are unable to resist actions being taken by a third party against them. They might be removed from the pub or club and taken somewhere quiet or unseen within the place, where they are then massively vulnerable to all kinds of abuse. In the Bill, we have referred to the reasons someone would do this, such as engaging in a sexual act, causing harm, making a gain, causing a loss or otherwise committing an offence. That covers a multitude of things. Of course, this includes rape, which is so often the consequence of spiking, so let us not in any way underestimate the seriousness of spiking, and where it happens, the effect it has on the individual concerned.

Most of us in this House will have dealt with constituents who have been the victims of spiking and the possible consequences of spiking up to and including rape. I am sorry to say I certainly have, so we cannot underestimate the seriousness of this matter or the effect it has on this person. Where we have set the tariff for penalties very much says this is a very serious thing. This is a very serious offence. It is not just taking away the autonomy of a person or removing their free will by drugging them, but it is also what is done to them while they are in that state. It is about making a very serious statement about the consequences for anybody who does this, what they are exposed to and with the indictment, it is ten years in prison. Members will know that the decision on whether it goes to the District or Circuit Court is one made by the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP. She will make an assessment based on the Garda investigation file and where it lies. However, in circumstances where we are dealing with the kind of things we are talking about here, I suggest these matters be tried on indictment if it goes that far or if the result of the spiking is the serious criminality I have described. In those circumstances, the person guilty of the offence would be exposed to ten years in prison. That is not in any way unreasonable or over-egged. This is serious stuff, and that is the point we are trying to make here. That is also why putting it on its own statutory footing clarifies any doubt there might be around where this lies in the canon of criminality. It is up there with the most serious offences. There will be no doubt now, when this Bill becomes law, that the people who engage in this kind of behaviour are engaged in serious criminal activity, up there with the worst of it and deserving of serious treatment by the courts.

There is one issue I want to deal with, which is a possible criticism of the Bill that has to be addressed. It is something Mary Crilly spoke to me about in the past week. That is whether there needs to be a statement in section 2(1)(c)(ii), which states that basically the offence is committed when the person intentionally administers a substance by whatever means and does so knowing the other person does not consent or it is reckless, but with the intention of overpowering or sedating the person for the purpose of the offence we are talking about.

The question then is: in a prosecution for spiking under this amendment to the Non-Fatal Offences against the Person Act, is it the case then that the court has to prove that there was intention? There is a concern among many quarters that proving that intention may be difficult and I acknowledge that as a legitimate criticism of the Bill. I have no difficulty, by the way, with amending that and I hope that when we get to the next Stage and deal with amendments from anywhere in this House that we would be able to address that concern, and maybe remove the reference to express intention. We could, maybe, talk about circumstances where it is reasonable to infer that this happened. There are lots of ways we can address that but if there is a flaw in this, in terms of creating an obligation on the prosecution to prove intention on the part of the spiking party, if I can say it that way, then let us address that.

What I want to acknowledge, because he is here, is that Deputy Mark Ward also brought forward a Bill on this subject in the past month, I think, or certainly in the past few weeks. We have had a conversation about this. Sinn Féin clearly acknowledges - as do Labour, the Social Democrats and other parties and Members with whom I have had discussions - that this is an issue that needs to be addressed, so I welcome what I hope will be cross-party support for this.

In regard to making this Bill better, we are open to whatever it is that is required to improve it. If it is the case that the issue of intention needs to be addressed, then I am open to amending the Bill accordingly to ensure it reflects the best possible iteration of a criminal offence that can be successfully prosecuted in our courts, that does not lead to ambiguity, or that does not lead to a situation where a person who has been involved in very serious criminal activity can find a way to escape the provisions of the legislation that we have, in good faith, set out with a view to dealing with exactly this problem.

I do not come here with this Bill suggesting that it is perfect. It is, of course, a matter for this House as to how the final iteration of the Bill comes about. I know the Minister for justice is here and that the matter was considered by Cabinet this week, and I look forward to hearing what he has to say. I welcome the serious and considered approach that Cabinet has taken to this Bill, and I would welcome hearing what the Minister has to say in that regard.

What we have here is an opportunity as a Legislature, with a Bill that has already gone through one of the Houses, to make a very clear statement of our intention - if I could put it that way - to mark this kind of behaviour as absolutely unacceptable and deeply damaging to the victims of that behaviour, and as something we as a State take incredibly seriously, that we will not tolerate and that we are willing to put on a statutory footing to say, "No further with this. No doubt about this". If you are spiking, you will be punished, prosecuted and you will go to jail. There are serious consequences to this. It is a serious legislative statement that anybody involved in this kind of appalling behaviour will suffer the full rigours of the law and the full criticism and penalties available to the court, and they will be held responsible...

[Click here to read the full debate on the Oireachtas website]

Repository Staff Only: item control page