McNeill, Fergus (2024) Probation, rehabilitation and reparation. Irish Probation Journal, 21, pp. 9-26.
External website: https://www.probation.ie/EN/PB/0/0ABA584C00291E828...
In Scotland and in England and Wales, recent reports and policy documents have sought to recast community penalties as ‘payback’. Though the precise meanings of this term and the practices associated with it differ quite significantly in the two jurisdictions, it can be argued in both contexts that the concept of reparation may be supplanting rehabilitation as the dominant penal rationale within probation work. This paper seeks to place these current developments in historical context by exploring how rehabilitation has been understood, practised, celebrated and criticised over the course of probation’s history. It goes on to examine what aspects and forms of rehabilitation we should seek to defend and retain, and what forms of reparation are most consistent with probation’s traditions and values and most likely to be effective in delivering justice and reducing crime.
[Note: This paper is a version of the 2nd Annual Martin Tansey Memorial Lecture, organised by the Association for Crime and Justice Research and delivered on 7 May 2009 at the Dublin Regional Office of the Probation Service in Ireland. It appeared in vol. 6 of the Irish Probation Journal (2009).
MM-MO Crime and law > Criminal penalty / sentence
MM-MO Crime and law > Criminal penalty / sentence > Community service > Probation or parole
MM-MO Crime and law > Justice and enforcement system
T Demographic characteristics > Person who commits a criminal offence (offender)
VA Geographic area > Europe > Ireland
Repository Staff Only: item control page